DOE-STD-1190-2007, Illness and Injury Surveillance Program Guidelines
Functional areas: Health, Hazards
The purpose of this standard is to assist DOE and its contractors in the conduct of the Illness and Injury Surveillance Program (IISP). IISP assists DOE in meeting its responsibility to monitor the health of its workforce at DOE sites in order to identify health hazards in the workplace. Canceled 8-23-2016.
Version history and related documents
Document text
Text extracted from the attached file. Refer to the original document for the authoritative version.
Section 1
DOE-STD-1190-2007
DOE STANDARD
ILLNESS AND INJURY SURVEILLANCE PROGRAM
GUIDELINES
U.S. Department of Energy AREA OCSH
Washington, D.C. 20585
DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT A. Approved for public release; distribution is unlimited.
NOT MEASUREMENT
SENSITIVE
DOE-STD-1190-2007
Available on the Department of Energy
Technical Standards Program
Web site at
http://tis.eh.doe.gov/techstds/
DOE-STD-1190-2007
Foreword
1. Use of this standard is not mandatory. Users should review the document and determine if it
meets their purpose.
2. Comments (recommendations, additions, and deletions) that may be of use in improving this
document should be addressed to: U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Health, c/o Dr. Cliff
Strader, HS-13/270 Corporate Square Building, 1000 Independence Avenue, SW,
Washington, DC 20585-0270.
3. This standard was developed through a consensus process by staff operating the DOE Illness
and Injury Surveillance Program with expert review by data coordinators who report
information to the Program. It was developed to facilitate the routine collection, analysis,
and dissemination of information on the health of DOE contractor and subcontractor
workers.
DOE-STD-1190-2007
1
TABLE OF CONTENTS
FOREWORD
1. SCOPE ............................................................................................................................................ 2
2. PURPOSE........................................................................................................................................ 2
3. BACKGROUND ............................................................................................................................ 2
3.1 Illness and Injury Surveillance Mission.................................................................................... 2
3.2 Illness and Injury Surveillance Program Organization............................................................. 3
4. DATA COMPONENTS OF ILLNESS AND INJURY SURVEILLANCE AT DOE SITES....... 4
4.1 Data Elements ........................................................................................................................... 5
4.2 Data Preparation and Submission ............................................................................................. 8
4.3 Worker Confidentiality Protection............................................................................................ 8
5. Types of Illness and Injury Health Events...................................................................................... 9
5.1 Return To Work. ................................................................................................................... 10
5.2 Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) Recordable events. ...................... 11
5.3 Disability (DIS)....................................................................................................................... 13
5.4 Death of an Active Worker (DEA). ........................................................................................ 14
6. Other Data Collection ................................................................................................................... 14
6.1 Monitoring Data: ................................................................................................................... 15
6.2 Administrative Data:............................................................................................................... 16
6.3 Quality Assurance................................................................................................................... 17
Section 2
7. ANALYSES AND REPORTS ..................................................................................................... 18
Appendix A – Monitoring Codes
Appendix B – Standardized Occupational Categories
DOE-STD-1190-2007
2
1. SCOPE
This standard provides recommended guidelines for the performance of Illness and Injury
Surveillance by occupational medicine programs at Department of Energy (DOE)-owned and
operated sites and at DOE-owned, contractor-operated sites regulated by the Atomic Energy Act,
Energy Reorganization Act of 1974, and Department of Energy Organization Act, 1977. The
aforementioned Acts state that DOE has the legislative mandate to monitor the impact of its
operations on the environment, the health of its workforce, and the residents of communities
surrounding DOE sites.
2. PURPOSE
The purpose of this standard is to assist DOE and its contractors in the conduct of the Illness and
Injury Surveillance Program (IISP). IISP assists DOE in meeting its responsibility to monitor the
health of its workforce at DOE sites in order to identify health hazards in the workplace. Use of this
standard will facilitate the initiation and efficient performance of Illness and Injury Surveillance
Program duties at DOE sites.
The Illness and Injury Program recruits selected DOE sites to participate in this voluntary program.
Participating sites can use the standard to clarify which data are requested for submission to the data
center and how often submissions should be made. Use of the recommendations presented in the
standard will enhance the performance of the program through improvement in the standardization
and completeness of data necessary for basic epidemiologic surveillance of worker health and
safety. Adherence to the guidance in the standard will produce higher quality data, and the quality
of information derived from analyses of these data will lead to a better understanding of the health
and safety status of workers at participating sites.
3. BACKGROUND
3.1 Illness and Injury Surveillance Mission
Illness and injury surveillance contributes to the overall Office of Illness and Injury
Prevention Programs (HS-13) (formerly known as the Office of Occupational Health)
mission to protect and promote the health of DOE workers. The goal of illness and injury
surveillance is to assess morbidity and the overall health of the DOE workforce in order to
DOE-STD-1190-2007
3
identify groups that may be at increased risk of occupationally related illness or injury. In
this manner, the program identifies opportunities for interventions that reduce or eliminate
risks to worker health. Illness and injury surveillance also provides a means by which the
effectiveness of these corrective actions can be evaluated.
While the identity of individual workers is protected, illness and injury surveillance
undertakes regular and systematic collection, analysis, and interpretation of data on illness
and injury in the DOE workforce in order to:
a. Determine the rates of illness and injury among workers,
b. Identify increases in the risk of disease among workers,
c. Provide information in response to questions from workers, medical staffs, Safety
and Health management, labor, and others about possible occupational health effects,
and
d. Identify areas in which further investigation or studies should be initiated.
The program provides health information about the DOE contractor and subcontractor labor
Section 3
force, for Headquarters and field management, administrators, medical staffs, and labor
groups, and facilitates timely response to health concerns raised by any of these affected
groups.
3.2 Illness and Injury Surveillance Program Organization
The Office of Illness and Injury Prevention Programs at DOE Headquarters is responsible
for establishing the IISP and setting policy and standards for the program. The Program is
coordinated by the program manager with technical assistance provided by the IISP Data
Center staff at the Oak Ridge Institute for Science and Education (ORISE). The Office of
Illness and Injury Prevention Programs is also responsible for the analysis and interpretation
of the Program’s data and the generation of final reports based on these analyses. The
program manager works with analysts at the Data Center and site staff to identify areas in
which further investigation might be needed.
DOE-STD-1190-2007
4
ORISE, under contract to the Office of Illness and Injury Prevention Programs, serves as the
Illness and Injury Surveillance Data Center. The Data Center collects the data, checks for
errors, ensures integrity of the data, manages the Illness and Injury Surveillance database,
provides quality assurance, and analyzes the data. The Data Center is also responsible for
coding diagnostic information in a standardized manner by trained nosologists. On request,
the Data Center will return a copy of all coded data to the site that initially submitted it for
use by on site analysts. The Data Center prepares initial drafts of reports that include an
analysis of the observed illness and injury trends and provide information for “quick
response” requests from DOE HQ or a participating site.
Each facility selects a site data coordinator who takes primary responsibility for
coordinating the collection and transmission of surveillance data to the Data Center. The
site data coordinator is the primary IISP point of contact at the site and coordinates with
other site staff who participate as needed. The site data coordinator is expected to have
training and experience in areas such as medical terminology, medical records or data
management, direct or indirect access to the medical, safety (OSHA), and roster data, and an
understanding of the organization of the site that facilitates identification of persons in the
organizations responsible for the various data required for illness and injury surveillance.
4. DATA COMPONENTS OF ILLNESS AND INJURY
SURVEILLANCE AT DOE SITES
Data collection focuses on contractor and subcontractor workers who are eligible to obtain return-
to-work (RTW) clearances through the site occupational medicine clinic, and for whom the
necessary personnel and medical records are available. The health data of subcontractor workers
who are not required to clear through the contractor's medical system are not accessible to the IISP;
they are, therefore, not included in illness and injury surveillance. Federal workers are not included
in the IISP because they are not generally required to use the on site medical clinics and are not
governed by the Occupational Safety and Health Act in the same manner as the Act addresses the
safety and health of contractor workers. Several different types of information must be identified
by the site Illness and Injury Surveillance data coordinator before data collection can proceed. It is
Section 4
the site data coordinator's responsibility to identify the organizations that maintain these data and to
DOE-STD-1190-2007
5
arrange access to the needed information. The data are generally gathered from Personnel (for
demographic information), Benefits (for disability retirement and death information), Medical (for
return-to-work clearance data), and Safety departments (for OSHA logs). The DOE Headquarters-
based Computerized Accident/Injury Reporting System (CAIRS) program may be able to supply
OSHA data in lieu of the on site Safety departments.
Basic data collection includes:
a. Roster of the current contractor and subcontractor workforce eligible to use the
site medical clinic
b. Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) No. 300 log entries,
c. Data from visits to Occupational Medicine for treatment/evaluation of some
health concern or condition, and return-to-work clearance data
d. Disability retirement data for actively employed workers on the roster
e. Deaths among actively employed workers on the roster, including cause of death
information from a death certificate (or similar type of record, such as a medical
report or autopsy report)
4.1 Data Elements
Data are organized into three groups for transmission to the Data Center. These groups are:
(1) roster data, (2) illness and injury data, and (3) site specific data, including any additional
data provided to the Data Center for analysis at the site’s request.
4.1.1 Roster data include information concerning all contractor and subcontractor
workers who are covered by DOE Rule 10 CFR 851 (Worker Health and
Safety Rule). Information on the number and characteristics of workers on the
roster are used to calculate the observed and expected rates of health events
that occur in the workforce.
DOE-STD-1190-2007
6
The D
Roster
Data Element Name
Description
1.
*Site Code
A unique code that identifies the site. Site code
is provided by ORISE Data Center.
2.
*Unique worker ID
Unique worker identification number associated
with each worker in order to link records. ID to
be determined by site. The unique ID number is
never changed for a worker and is never
reassigned, should a worker leave the workforce.
A worker who leaves the workforce and later
returns should receive his/her original ID
number.
3.
*YearBorn
Year of birth (Must be in format of YYYY.)
4.
*Gender
Gender of worker. Accepted values: M,F
5.
*First Hire on Site Date
Date the worker was first hired to work on
current DOE site (MM/DD/YYYY). Human
Resources data should be utilized, but medical
records may have this data. The First Hire Date
is not identical to the Service Date, which often
changes when contractors change under a new
contract. To protect worker identity, this date
may be submitted as MM/YYYY.
6.
Contractor Name
The employer of the individual
7.
Organization/Location
Generally offered as coded indicators of the
specific organization and physical location at
which work is performed. For workers whose
jobs involve significant mobility around the site,
the location code may be the physical location of
primary assignment or the place at which the
employee would receive mail.
8.
Job Title
The employer’s administrative job title for the
position held by the employee.
9.
Occupational Group Standardized Categories, See Appendix B. Data
coordinators are expected to work with
appropriate site personnel to classify individuals
into one of these categories, based on the
primary tasks they perform.
Section 5
10.
Pay Status
Salaried or Hourly. Accepted values:
A,B,C,E,F,G,H,L,M,N,P,R,S,T,W
11.
Dosimeter Assignment
Status
Indicates whether or not a dosimeter is currently
assigned. Accepted values: Y,N
*Data elements marked with an asterisk indicate required fields.*
DOE-STD-1190-2007
7
4.1.2 Illness and injury data provide adverse health outcome information on
members of the current workforce identified in the rosters. A detailed
explanation of illness and injury data elements is provided in Section 5.
4.1.3 Site Specific Data include additional data identified and provided by individual
DOE sites at the site’s discretion. Sites may wish to conduct illness and injury
surveillance on a particular group of workers defined by a common exposure,
workplace, enrollment in a wellness or monitoring program, or other variable
of interest. The Data Center will manage these data and conduct analyses using
them at the request of the site. A site must obtain guidance from the DOE
Office of Illness and Injury Prevention Programs before submitting site-
specific data. Each site that submits site-specific data must provide a data
element name, definition, and determine a coding scheme for each variable
specified. This information will be provided to the Data Center with separate
coding documentation created by the site’s surveillance staff. Special analyses
can then be scheduled in consultation with cognizant site staff to address the
site’s needs. The Data Center can provide advice and consultation in the
development of coding schemes on request from the site.
4.1.4 Conduct of Epidemiological Studies by Site Staff
The Office of Health supports the conduct of epidemiological investigations by
site staff. However, it is necessary that site staff inform the DOE Office of
Illness and Injury Prevention Programs (HS-13) of the proposed study prior to
initiation. A copy of the study protocol, methodology, and evidence of a
completed Institutional Review Board (IRB) review should be sent to the
Director of the Office of Health. Copies of all reports and summaries prepared
by site staff as part of their investigation should be submitted to the Office
Director of HS-13 at the close of the investigation.
DOE-STD-1190-2007
8
4.2 Data Preparation and Submission Schedule
Participating sites generate a complete, unabridged roster as of January 1 of each calendar
year and generate updated rosters each quarter. Quarterly updates are generated
approximately April 1, July 1, and October 1 of each year. Updated rosters may be
submitted more frequently at the site’s discretion. Arrangements for roster submissions on
an alternative schedule must be made with the Data Center. Illness and injury data including
selected information about various types of adverse health events must be reported monthly
to the Data Center. Submissions are due at the Data Center by the 15th day of the following
month; however, as stated previously, some sites have made arrangements to submit their
data on a different schedule depending on their internal data capture systems. OSHA data
are also submitted on a monthly basis when the site elects to capture these data directly from
a source in their Safety organization. If annual CAIRS data submissions are substituted,
only an annual submission is expected in conformance with the CAIRS program’s data
submission requirements.
4.3 Worker Confidentiality Protection
Section 6
All data submitted to the Data Center contain unique, coded identification (ID) numbers to
link the records of a particular worker. Each site should assign every worker on the roster a
unique, permanent, coded ID number to protect the confidentiality of the worker included in
the database. Only this coded number is used to identify data pertaining to the worker.
Names, Social Security numbers, or other personal identification information will not appear
in the Illness and Injury Surveillance database. Encoding an identifier should not be based
on overly simplistic schemes, such as the reversal of the social security number, and must
not produce duplicate identifiers. Moreover, the encryption scheme should not be based on
an identifier such as a personnel number that is subject to change if there is a change in
contractors. Only one worker may be assigned to an identification number. If the worker
leaves the workforce, the identification number cannot be reassigned to a different
individual. A former worker returning to the workforce should be reassigned his/her
original identification number. Both numeric and alphanumeric identifiers are acceptable.
DOE-STD-1190-2007
9
Maintaining the confidentiality of information for each worker is of the highest importance;
therefore, the occupational medicine department at each site will assign every worker on the
roster a unique, permanent, coded identification number to be used on all data submitted for
illness and injury surveillance. In all communications with the Data Center at ORISE or the
Office of Illness and Injury Prevention Programs at DOE Headquarters, worker information
will reference only the coded identification number of the individual. All reports and
analyses that use worker information will be summarized and grouped so that individual
information cannot be disclosed or tracked back to a specific worker. These methods of
maintaining confidentiality minimize the possibility of violating privacy protections laws,
rules and standards.
The protection and use of DOE-owned personnel and medical records are regulated under
the authority of the Privacy Act of 1974 (5 USC 552a, as amended). Rules on the routine
use of these records are published in DOE implementing regulations (see Federal Register /
Vol. 68, No. 125 / Monday, June 30, 2003 page 38756.) Similar requirements exist for
contractor-owned medical records, which are regulated under authority of the Health
Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA). Department of Health and Human
Services (HHS) regulations implementing HIPAA are published in 45 Code of Federal
Regulations Parts 160, 162, and 164. The Department of Energy regulations implementing
the Privacy Act of 1974 are published in 10 Code of Federal Regulations Part 1008. For
those clinics operating under HHS guidelines for covered entities, the Illness and Injury
Surveillance Program has adapted its data requests to ensure that it accommodates the site’s
response to HHS requirements. These adaptations are managed on a site by site basis, often
taking the form of meeting site-determined criteria for de-identification of data. States also
require compliance with confidentiality protection rules and standards as conditions for
maintaining professional licenses.
5. Types of Illness and Injury Health Events
Four major categories of illness and injury events eligible for reporting to the Illness and
Section 7
Injury Surveillance Program are described below:
DOE-STD-1190-2007
10
5.1 Return To Work. These events consist of all illnesses and injuries reported by
workers who are required to clear through the site’s Occupational Medicine clinic to be
pronounced “fit-for-duty”. Health events are eligible for reporting regardless of whether
they are determined to be occupational. Return-to-work clearances indicate the number of
days absent, but alternative work schedules have become increasingly common and the
number of actual work days absent may be difficult to determine by examining the dates of
absence. Sites must identify methods to determine the length of absence when alternative
work schedules are involved. Although the Illness and Injury Surveillance Program accepts
illness absence data involving any length of absence, most analyses focus on those events
involving absences of 40 or more consecutive work hours. This analysis criterion is derived
from Order 10 CFR 851, which requires a fitness for duty examination at the occupational
medicine clinic following any occupational illness or injury, or when an employee returns
after five or more consecutive workdays of absence (or the equivalent period for a worker on
an alternative work schedule) for a non-occupational illness or injury. The data elements for
return-to-work events include:
Return-to-Work
Data Element Name
Description
1.
*Site Code
A unique code that identifies the site. Site code
is provided by ORISE Data Center.
2.
*Unique worker ID
Unique worker identification number associated
with each worker in order to link records. ID to
be determined by site. The unique ID number is
never changed for a worker and is never
reassigned, should a worker leave the workforce.
A worker who leaves the workforce and later
returns should receive his/her original
identification number.
3.
*Record Status
New, Change, Delete – Accepted values: N,C,D
4.
*Date began
Date absence began (MM/DD/YYYY)
5.
*Diagnosis
Provide the narrative description of the diagnosis
of illness or injury as reported by worker.
Supporting documentation from a personal
physician is not required but can be used to help
determine the diagnosis if available.
6.
*RTW date
Return-to-work date (MM/DD/YYYY)
*Data elements marked with an asterisk indicate required fields.*
DOE-STD-1190-2007
11
Diagnostic information will be abstracted from the medical clinic’s return-to-work
clearance form if applicable. The program does not require a personal physician’s
report; the worker’s self-reported reason for absence is sufficient. This information
will be used by trained nosologists at the Data Center to determine the proper
International Classification of Disease, 9th Revision Clinical Modification (ICD-9-
CM) codes for the health event in a standardized manner. A narrative description of
the diagnoses is preferred. Sites that code their diagnostic data using the ICD9-CM
codes submit only the coded information to the Data Center. If the Data Center’s
quality assurance procedures indicate that the site-coded diagnoses do not differ from
the Data Center’s codes, consideration will be given to allowing sites to submit the
ICD-9-CM codes in lieu of text. The level of agreement between site-generated ICD-
9-CM codes and those assigned by the Data Center’s nosologists will be assessed
periodically as part of the program’s quality assurance process.
Section 8
Some sites consider the reporting of the specific date an absence began and the return
to work date to be too explicit to conform to HIPAA privacy requirements. In lieu of
these dates, they calculate and report the duration of absence and provide a less precise
indication of the dates such as the month and year, but not the day of the event. If
needed to satisfy site-specific legal requirements, alternative reporting formats can be
arranged in consultation with the Data Center.
5.2 Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) Recordable events.
These data include all illnesses and injuries that are considered recordable as defined
by the Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970, and 29 CFR Part 1904. OSHA-
recordable events are those that occur on the job and involve: (1) fatalities, regardless
of time between injury and death, or the length of illness; (2) cases other than fatalities
that result in lost workdays; and (3) nonfatal cases without lost workdays that result in
transfer to another job or termination of employment, or require medical treatment
other than first aid or involve loss of consciousness or restriction of work or motion.
DOE-STD-1190-2007
12
Various methods of collecting OSHA data may be employed. Sites may either abstract
data from the OSHA No. 300 log or assemble the information from a related data base.
Alternatively, many sites have chosen to take advantage of the DOE Directive DOE O
231.1A, Environment, Safety, and Health Reporting, which contains the reporting
requirement that mandates an annual submission of OSHA data to CAIRS. A copy of
the annual CAIRS data can be returned to the data coordinator directly from CAIRS.
The data coordinator is then responsible for replacing personal identifiers from the
CAIRS data set with the Illness and Injury Surveillance Program’s coded identifier.
The de-identified data are then submitted to the program’s Data Center. It is important
to note that no DOE Headquarters staff involved with the IISP receives a copy of the
identified CAIRS data. Unless the site data coordinator believes that local sources of
OSHA data are more complete than the data submitted to CAIRS, this approach is
recommended because it is cost effective, comprehensive, maintains worker privacy
and confidentiality, and is consistent with the site’s reporting of occupational health
events to CAIRS.
The data elements collected from the OSHA No. 300 log or generated by the site’s
data coordinator include:
OSHA No. 300
Data Element Name
Description
1.
*Site Code
A unique code that identifies the site. Site code
is provided by ORISE Data Center.
2.
*Unique ID
Unique worker identification number associated
with each worker in order to link records. ID to
be determined by site. The unique ID number is
never changed for a worker and is never
reassigned, should a worker leave the workforce.
A worker who leaves the workforce and later
returns should receive his/her original
identification number.
3.
*Record status
New, Change, Delete. Accepted values: N,C,D
4. *Date of event
Column D of OSHA’s Form 300 (Rev. 01/2004)
5.
*Days lost due to injury Code for occupational injury without workday
loss/restriction (Note if Column J of OSHA’s
Form 300 (Rev. 01/2004) is checked and
Column M(1) is also checked.)
DOE-STD-1190-2007
13
6.
*Days restricted due to
injury
Column K of OSHA’s Form 300 (Rev. 01/2004),
to be filled in only if an illness is involved
Section 9
7.
*Occupational Injury Code Column L of OSHA’s Form 300 (Rev. 01/2004),
to be filled in only if an illness is involved
8.
*Days lost due to illness
Code for occupational illness without workday
loss/restriction(Note if Column J of OSHA’s
Form 300 (Rev. 01/2004) is checked and
Column M(2, 3, 4, 5, or 6) is also checked.)
9.
*Days restricted due to
illness
Illness or Injury, as described in columns E and
F of OSHA’s Form 300 (Rev. 01/2004)
10.
*Occupational Illness
Code
Coding cannot be provided without a description
of the event (see item 11)
11.
*Description of event A narrative description is necessary in order to
provide an occupational illness code. Otherwise
the event cannot be coded.
*Data elements marked with an asterisk indicate required fields.*
Clearly, some OSHA-recordable health events could involve long-term disability leave
followed by an eventual RTW clearance. In such cases the RTW clearance record for
such a worker would be reported as well as the worker’s OSHA recordable health
event.
5.3 Disability (DIS). These health events are the result of a disability that leads to
retirement. On notification from the Personnel Office (or other information source)
that a worker has left the work force due to a disability retirement, but no information
on the medical condition resulting in the disability retirement is available, site
occupational medicine staff are encouraged to contact the worker to obtain a diagnosis.
For a disability retirement, the data coordinator should report the following
information:
DOE-STD-1190-2007
14
Disability Retirement
Data Element Name
Description
1.
*Site Code
A unique code that identifies the site. Site code
is provided by ORISE Data Center.
2.
*Unique ID
Unique worker identification number associated
with each worker in order to link records. ID to
be determined by site. The unique ID number is
never changed for a worker and is never
reassigned, should a worker leave the workforce.
A worker who leaves the workforce and later
returns should receive his/her original
identification number.
3.
*Record status
New, Change, Delete. Accepted values: N,C,D
4.
*Term date
Date worker terminated employment
5.
*Diagnosis
Narrative description of the illness or injury
resulting in disability retirement
*Data elements marked with an asterisk indicate required fields.*
5.4. Death of an Active Worker (DEA). The date and cause of death of an
actively employed worker are reportable, when available. This information is usually
obtained from the death certificate or other reliable data source. Family members are
often required to submit copies of death certificates to the appropriate Human
Resources Office when they apply for survivor benefits, and these death certificates
can also assist determination of cause of death. Submit the following information:
Death of an active worker
Data Element Name
Description
1.
*Site Code
A unique code that identifies the site. Site code
is provided by ORISE Data Center.
2.
*Unique ID
Unique worker identification number
associated with each worker in order to link
records. ID to be determined by site. The
unique ID number is never changed for a
worker and is never reassigned, should a
worker leave the workforce. A worker who
leaves the workforce and later returns should
receive his/her original identification number.
Section 10
3.
*Record status
New, Change, Delete. Accepted values: N,C,D
4.
*Date of death
This the date of death of the employee
5.
*Immediate cause of death
The immediate cause of death is the disease
(condition) or complication that occurred
closest to the time of death.
*Data elements marked with an asterisk indicate required fields.*
DOE-STD-1190-2007
15
6. Other Data Collection
6.1 Monitoring Data: In the absence of specific industrial hygiene measurements, one
indirect indicator of potential exposures is the enrollment of workers in various
monitoring programs designed to detect exposure to potentially harmful substances.
Such enrollment provides an accessible, albeit crude, indicator of those workers at
greater risk of exposure to various substances with potential to affect their health. The
monitoring data collected by the IISP report the enrollment of an individual in various
monitoring programs found at DOE facilities such as lead monitoring, beryllium
monitoring, dosimetry, and periodic spirometry for respirator users. Appendix A
contains a coded list of the more common monitoring programs found at DOE facilities.
Data coordinators are urged to alert the Data Center and the IISP Program Director at
any time concerning new or additional monitoring programs that do not currently appear
in Appendix A.
Data to be reported for workers involved in one or more monitoring programs should be
submitted by January 31 and July 31 of each calendar year. Each submission reflects the
monitoring status of workers as of the beginning (January 1) and midpoint (July 1) of
that calendar year. Any participating site may aggregate the monitoring status of
workers on these two dates into one data file for submission by July 31 of each calendar
year: In this case, the data would include the monitoring status of workers for both the
beginning (January 1) and midpoint (July 1) of that calendar year. Data should be
included for each monitoring program in which the worker is enrolled, as indicated in
the table below. The following data elements should be reported for each monitoring
program in which the worker is enrolled. For workers involved in many monitoring
programs, coordinators can submit as many of these records per worker as required, but
should put only one monitoring code in each record.
For the monitoring program, the following information should be submitted:
DOE-STD-1190-2007
16
Monitoring Program
Data Element Name
Description
1.
*Site Code
A unique code that identifies the site. Site code
is provided by ORISE Data Center.
2.
*Unique ID
Unique worker identification number associated
with each worker in order to link records. ID to
be determined by site. The unique ID number is
never changed for a worker and is never
reassigned, should a worker leave the workforce.
A worker who leaves the workforce and later
returns should receive his/her original
identification number.
3.
*Monitoring code
Indicates specialized monitoring program in
which an individual may participate (e.g.,
asbestos, beryllium) See Appendix A
4.
*Start date
The date on which the individual was enrolled in
the monitoring program.
5.
*Stop date
The date on which the individual’s enrollment in
the monitoring program ended
6.
*Record status
New, Change, Delete. Accepted values: N,C,D
*Data elements marked with an asterisk indicate required fields.*
Section 11
6.2 Administrative Data: The Illness and Injury Surveillance Program collects
administrative data in order to assess the completeness of reporting from participating
sites on an unscheduled basis. The IISP uses these data only for quality assurance
purposes. These data are not part of routine reporting. Administrative data elements
include beginning and end dates of absences noted as sick leave in Human Resources
time and attendance reporting data. They are compared with illness related absences
reported through the return to work clearance process. The comparison provides an
indication of the completeness of absence ascertainment derived from return to work
clearance data.
DOE-STD-1190-2007
17
The administrative data collected are minimal, generally including only the following
data elements:
Administrative
Data Element Name
Description
1.
*Site Code
A unique code that identifies the site. Site code
is provided by ORISE Data Center.
2.
*Unique ID
Unique worker identification number associated
with each worker in order to link records. ID to
be determined by site. The unique ID number is
never changed for a worker and is never
reassigned, should a worker leave the workforce.
A worker who leaves the workforce and later
returns should receive his/her original
identification number.
3.
*Beginning date of
absence
The first day of absence as indicated by reported
sick leave from time and attendance records
4.
*End date of absence
The day on which an absence ends, as indicated
by reported sick leave from time and attendance
records
5.
*Record status
New, Change, Delete. Accepted values: N,C,D
*Data elements marked with an asterisk indicate required fields.*
6.3 Quality Assurance
The purpose of all quality assurance monitoring is to ensure the unimpeded flow of
accurate, complete data to the Data Center. The administrative data described above are
used to assess completeness of reporting absences related to illness or injury through
comparisons of the occupational medicine clinic’s RTW data with the absences
identified through time and attendance information collected by the Payroll Office.
A second type of quality assurance addresses our concern that sites which provide only
ICD-9-CM codes instead of a narrative explanation of diagnoses must have a high level
of agreement with the nosologic coding provided by the Data Center. To address this
concern, about two percent of records are randomly selected by the Data Center
periodically for coding comparisons. The Data Center evaluates coded data for accuracy
and completeness of the information in its data base compared with the information
available on hard copy records. The resulting error rate information is then provided to
DOE-STD-1190-2007
18
the site data coordinator. If quality assurance issues are detected, continued quality
assurance monitoring of the site’s data submissions will be conducted to evaluate the
success of corrective actions at the site.
7. ANALYSES AND REPORTS
The IISP’s various workforce health evaluations, periodic surveillance activities, and special
investigations involve the publication of numerous reports. Annual site-specific summary reports
present workforce demographics, summarize illness and injury health event absences, and present
rates of occurrence of selected diseases and injuries, both occupational and non-occupational, for an
Section 12
individual site. Periodically the IISP also publishes rollup reports that emphasize the assessment of
broad trends and the overall experience of the DOE workforce at major categories of facilities, e.g.,
decommissioning and decontamination, research and development, and weapons facilities.
Additional reports address particular occupational groups or diagnosis categories of interest; recent
assessments have evaluated trends in hypertension and diabetes among DOE’s aging workers.
Special topic reports can examine particular types of injury or illness or evaluate a broader spectrum
of health issues in a particular segment of the workforce, such as a particular occupational group,
age group, or gender. The IISP also supports special investigations initiated in response to worker
health concerns at a site, issues noted by site medical or safety personnel, or reviews undertaken in
response to management concerns. These investigations are summarized in final reports that are
made available on the program’s internet home page upon release. In all cases, only summaries and
aggregate data are presented in IISP reports, ensuring the privacy of all workers employed at
participating sites.
The distribution of information from Illness and Injury Surveillance analyses targets a broad
audience, including workers and their organized labor management representatives; the
occupational medicine departments at DOE sites; Headquarters and site Environment, Safety and
Health management; and the Office of Illness and Injury Prevention Programs at DOE
Headquarters. Distribution takes the form of both hard copy and Internet publication, with
electronic notification to interested stakeholders when relevant reports are published on the Office
of Illness and Injury Prevention Programs Internet home page at
http://www.eh.doe.gov/health/epi/surv/index.html.. Reports are made available to the general
DOE-STD-1190-2007
19
public through DOE’s reading rooms located at or near DOE sites throughout the United States, and
access to the reports is available to the public on our Internet home page.
DOE-STD-1190-2007
20
APPENDIX A
CODES FOR ROSTER DATA ELEMENT ‘MONITOR’
Indicates any specialized monitoring program in which an individual participates (e.g.,
beryllium, lead, asbestos, regular urinalysis sampling, etc.).
Monitoring codes are as follows:
Surveillance Programs
S001 Asbestos Worker
S002 Benzene Worker
S003 Beryllium Worker
S004 Cadmium Worker
S005 Carcinogens Worker
S006 Formaldehyde Worker
S007 Hazardous Waste Workers/
HAZMAT
S008 Hearing Conservation/Protection
S009 Lead Worker
S010 Radiation Worker
Certification Programs
C001 Crane Operator (incidental)
C002 Crane Operator (Professional)
C003 DOT Driver
C004 FAA Class I Pilot
C005 FAA Class 11 Other Flight
Personnel
C006 Fire Department/Emergency
Brigade
C007 Fissile Material Handler
C008 Forklift Operator (incidental)
C009 Forklift Operator (Professional)
C010 Heavy Equipment Operator
C011 Laser Operator
C012 Nonreactor Nuclear Facility
Operator
C013 Nuclear Material Handler (CPP
only)
C014 Personnel Security Assurance
Program (PSAP)
C015 Personnel Security Sensitive
(PSS)/Human Reliability Program
C016 QA/Nondestructive Test Inspector
C017 Reactor Operator
C018 Respirator User
C019 Rigger
C020 Security Force
C021 Test Designated Position (TDP)
C022 Welder
DOE-STD-1190-2007
21
C023 Security Inspector (defensive)
C024 Security Inspector (offensive)
Additional Codes
Section 13
A001 1,1,1-Trichloroethane
A002 Alkanes
A003 Antimony
A004 Best Team
A005 Carbon Monoxide
A006 Carbon Tetrachloride
A007 Ceramic Fibers
A008 Chloroform
A009 Chromates/Chromium
A010 Cobalt
A011 Confined Space
A012 Cyanide
A013 Diver
A014 Driver (non-DOT)
A015 Health Care Personnel
A016 Heat/Hot Environment
A017 Heights
A018 Isocyanates
Additional Codes (continued)
A019 Laboratory Workers
A020 Management or Executive health
monitoring
A021 Mercury
A022 Methylene Chloride
A023 Methylene Dianiline (MDA)
A024 Nickel
A025 Painters
A026 Pesticide
A027 Polychlorinated biphenyls (PCB)
A028 Radiation: Internal Burden
A029 Tetrachloroethylene
A030 Titanium
A031 Toluene
A032 Transportation, Department of (DOT)
A033 Trichloroethylene
A034 Zinc
A035 Nanotechnology worker
DOE-STD-1190-2007
22
APPENDIX B
STANDARDIZED OCCUPATIONAL CATEGORIES
Management (M) – Predominately office work at a desk; first level supervisor and above;
anticipated risks primarily ergonomic
Administrative Support (A) – Predominately office work at a desk; heavy computer usage;
anticipated risks primarily ergonomic. This category includes but is not limited to information
technology, clerical, and secretarial staff.
In-House Professionals (I)– Predominately office work at a desk typically without supervisory
responsibilities. The risks are primarily ergonomic.
Field Professionals (F)– Frequently works outside of their office in areas such as but not
limited to laboratories, testing areas, and construction areas. Potential for exposure to chemical
or radiation hazards.
Technical Support (T)– Workers who typically support the field professionals and have
hands-on work situations. Potential for exposure to chemical or radiation hazards; the potential
for exposure may be higher than for the field professionals.
Biohazard (B)– Workers who have the potential for exposure to biological hazards. This
includes medical technicians, nurses, laboratory staff, animal caretakers, physicians, and
veterinarians.
Service (S)– Typically includes but is not limited to custodians, drivers, laborers, laundry
workers, linemen, mail clerks, pilots, railroad engineers, records center workers, stationary
engineers, utility workers, and water plant operators. These workers support and maintain the
facility’s infrastructure and have the potential for a broad range of exposures. Most work is not
performed sitting at a desk.
Security and Fire (E) – Typically includes protective forces and firefighters.
Crafts (C) – Typically includes bargaining unit employees and laborers. They have the
potential for a broad range of exposures.
Line Operators (O)–Typically workers who are involved in process, operation, or line
activities at the facility. Potential for chemical and/or radiation exposure on a regular basis.
DOE-STD-1190-2007
23
Guests (G) – Employees on short-term assignments or internships. Typically includes guest
scientists, postdoctoral fellows, co-op students, and interns. Potential for exposure dependent
on job assignment.
Unknown (U) – Job title is missing.
DOE-STD-1190-2007
24
CONCLUDING MATERIAL
Review Activity: Preparing Activity:
DOE Field Offices DOE-HS-13
NA AL
EE CH Project Number:
EH ID OCSH-0005
EM OH
SC RL
FE RP
NE SR
RW
National Laboratories
BNL NTS
LLNL ORNL
LANL Pantex
ETTP SNL
INL SRS
KCP Y-12