DOE-HDBK-1143-2001 Part 5, Radiological Control Training for Supervisors - Part 5, Student's Guide
Functional areas: Radiological Control Training, Supervisors, Student's Guide, Training
This handbook describes a Radiological Control Training for Supervisors program. It includes standards and policies as well as recommendations for material development and program administration. It is intended for use by DOE and DOE contractors for the development of facility-specific radiological control training for supervisors.
Unknown Block text
Superseded By:
Version history and related documents
Superseded by
A newer version replaces this document.
Document text
Text extracted from the attached file. Refer to the original document for the authoritative version.
Section 1
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
I. Introduction
II. Problem analysis
Supervisors of radiological workers are often faced
with critical decisions. Providing a model for strategic
decision making will ensure that these critical
decisions are made in an efficient, rational manner.
Module 6-1
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
A. Stating the mission
In making decisions, the organization’s mission
and resultant goals should always be considered.
Decisions should be consistent with the stated
mission of the organization. Prior to decision
making, the organization’s mission must be
defined. This may be difficult if the organization’s
mission has not been defined or if there are
conflicting goals within the organization.
B. Assessing internal and external environments
Prior to making a decision or solving a problem,
the problem must be identified and evaluated to
ensure that all factors have been included in the
problem statement.
1. Problem diagnosis - Identify the problem.
2. Problem specification - Clarify the specific
nature of the problem.
3. Problem framing - Frame the problem in a
nonjudgmental way.
4. Problem formulation and reformulation -
Restructure the problem in a way that will
make it easier to solve. This can be done by
introducing accurate assumptions.
Module 6-2
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
III. Decision making
A. Developing strategy
Once the problem has been identified, alternative
solutions must be generated. A general rule for
decision making is as follows: if an acceptable
standard solution is available to a problem, then it
should be used instead of spending time and
resources reinventing a solution. If a standard
solution is not available, alternatives must be
developed.
1. Standard solutions involve using standard
operating procedures as well as available
alternatives. Optimization techniques, which
include cost-benefit analysis, are a
fundamental part of work reviews and of
radiological analyses for new designs and
modifications. For review of minor or routine
activities with low associated doses, a cost-
benefit evaluation may be an intrinsic part of
the engineering or operations review process,
so a detailed evaluation is usually not
necessary. For review and planning of major
tasks involving higher collective dose
expenditures, a detailed and documented
evaluation should be performed.
2. A simple optimization decision may be made
by choosing a low-current-dose worker
instead of a high-dose worker or by declining
to spend a large sum to save only a few
mrem. Note that the writing of work planning
documents (e..g., Radiological Work Permits,
work packages, procedures, etc.) is also an
optimization evaluation, in which the line
supervisor must usually concur.
Module 6-3
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
Although the supervisor may not have to
perform detailed optimization
Evaluation, that information may need to be
provided to the person(s) who will do the
evaluation.
Such information will often be based on past
operating experience and may include costs
of equipment, person-hours, number of
people, amount of time spent in radiological
areas, and even subjective judgments
regarding the feasibility of alternatives.
Section 2
B. Limits on decision making
1. When supervisors make decisions, they need
to determine how much power they have in
reaching a final decision and how much
influence they have over the process. This is
important information when considering the
most appropriate alternatives.
2. The decision maker must also determine what
the political impact of various decisions will
be. There may be political reasons why the
most rational solution is not feasible.
3. When selecting an alternative, it is important
to consider the repercussions of not selecting
various alternatives. If there is strong
opposition to a selected alternative, the
decision maker needs to be able to support
the current decision and explain why the
competing solution is less feasible or less
desirable.
Module 6-4
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
C. Making the decision
The formal decision analysis will be as follows:
• Define alternative courses of action,
determine the criteria to use in evaluating the
alternatives, and identify key uncertainties in
the decision.
• Assess the consequences of selecting each
alternative.
• Assess the probabilities and preferences by
looking at the uncertainties and utilities of
each outcome.
• Evaluate alternatives in terms of the stated
criteria.
• Analyze the optimal solutions for any adverse
consequences.
• Select the most effective solution based on
problem analysis.
D. Implementation and controlling execution of
strategy
Once a decision is made, the decision will be
implemented and evaluated. It is important to
monitor events after implementation to ensure
that the outcomes are as expected. If not, it may
be necessary to revise the original decision.
Monitoring outcomes of decisions will also
provide lessons learned for future decision
making.
E. Case studies
Module 6-5
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
This page intentionally left blank.
Module 6-6
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
I. Introduction
II. Motivation
The roles and responsibilities of a supervisor include
motivating personnel to perform quality work. There
are many theories of motivation. Some have been
found to be effective and some have not. It is
important for supervisors to understand which
theories of motivation are valid and which techniques
will be most effective.
III. Why are people motivated?
A. Needs fulfillment theories
Need fulfillment theories of motivation state that
people are motivated by inherent needs and
specifically by unmet needs. Behavior is based
on inherent needs.
1. Maslow's hierarchy of needs
1. Physiological
2. Safety
3. Belongingness
4. Love
5. Self-actualization
Module 7–1
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
In an organization, one typically assumes that
an individual's basic needs have been met
(food, shelter, clothing). However, other
needs may not have been met. Supervisors
should be aware of employees' need for a
safe and secure working environment. This is
a critical issue for supervisors of radiological
workers.
It is not the organization's responsibility to
Section 3
fulfill higher level needs (belongingness, love,
self-actualization). However, supervisors
should understand how these needs translate
into motivation. If employees feel like they are
part of a work team, they will be more loyal,
and perhaps be motivated to work harder.
The need for self-actualization can often be
encouraged by providing employees with the
authority to make decisions that are critical to
their working environment.
2. Job enrichment theory
The job enrichment theory of motivation states
that certain job dimensions will motivate
employees to work more effectively.
Job dimensions include the following:
• Skill variety
• Task identity
• Task significance
• Autonomy
• Feedback
These job dimensions will provide meaning to
the job, make an employee responsible for the
job, and provide feedback concerning how the
job is progressing.
Module 7–2
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
Supervisors should evaluate the jobs of their
workers to determine if these dimensions are
part of the job. If not, the need for job
redesign may be indicated.
3. Need for achievement theory
In this theory, it is believed that some
employees have a need for achievement,
while others do not. If a person has a high
need for achievement, he/she will do better in
"achieving situations." These situations may
be characterized as follows:
• Personal responsibility is evident. The
individual will receive credit for a job well
done.
• The task should be at an intermediate to
average level of difficulty. There should be
a good chance of success.
• The individual needs to receive feedback.
• The individual needs to feel challenged.
• The situation should be ongoing, with
consequences in the future.
Although a supervisor cannot change an
individual's need for achievement,
understanding this theory may explain what
motivates some employees.
B. Cognitive theories
Cognitive theories of motivation state that a
person's behavior is based on a cognitive
process. People think before they act.
Module 7–3
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
1. Equity (justice) theory
This theory is based on the equity of input
(work) and output (rewards). Employees'
output is based on their perceived level of
their own input, as well as their perception of
the input and output of others.
If employees believe that their input is greater
than that of others (or their output is less),
they will try to balance the situation by doing
the following:
• Reducing their input (decreased
productivity, absenteeism, tardiness)
• Increasing their rewards (employee theft,
i.e., supplies, phone calls, inflated expense
statements)
• Leaving the job in search of a more
equitable situation
Supervisors should be aware of this theory
and assess whether there is equity in the
workplace for each worker as well as across
the team. By understanding the equity theory,
supervisors can understand behaviors
stemming from real or perceived inequities.
2. Expectancy (choice) theory
For the expectancy theory, the primary
motivation is the attainment of goals.
Behavior is based on a person's expectation
that his or her effort will lead to a certain type
of performance. This in turn will lead to a
certain level of reward (e.g., If I work hard, I
will do a good job and get a good reward).
Employees make clear choices about the
level of effort they will exert based on these
expectations.
Section 4
Module 7–4
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
For employees to be motivated, there must be
a clearly defined relationship between
performance and rewards (compensation
system). There also has to be a link between
effort and performance. The supervisor must
be aware of an individual's effort and
consequent performance.
The supervisor must provide feedback to the
employee that will enable the link between
effort and performance to be more direct.
C. Reinforcement theories
The basic tenet underlying reinforcement theories
is that people are motivated by rewards for their
behavior. People work because they are
rewarded. A reward is considered something of
value to the employee. The most basic is
compensation (pay, benefits, leave time). Other
rewards include recognition and job prerequisites.
Following this theory, supervisors should assess
the rewards and recognition given to their
employees.
IV. Tools of motivation
A. Goal setting
Goal setting is one of the most researched areas
of motivation, the basic conclusion is that goals
motivate people. A goal is something that a
person tries to attain, achieve, or accomplish.
Once a goal is set, behavior is based on the
attainment of that goal. Specific goal-setting
techniques will be presented later.
Module 7–5
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
Why do goals work?
• Goals give an employee direction.
• Goals influence the intensity with which an
individual works toward attainment of a goal.
• Goals influence the persistence with which an
individual works toward attainment of a goal.
• Goals typically require individuals to develop a
strategy for goal attainment.
For goals to be effective motivators, they must
have the following characteristics:
1. Goal difficulty
Employees become more committed to
difficult goals. If a goal is too easy,
employees will not seriously commit to goal
attainment because there is no challenge.
However, if the goal is too difficult, employees
will not make a commitment because they
don't believe they can accomplish the goal.
2. Goal specificity
The more specific a goal, the easier it is to
achieve. Specific goals provide more detailed
direction toward attaining that goal.
3. Employee participation in goal setting
An individual must internalize a given goal
before it becomes a motivation. The best way
to do this is for the individual to participate in
setting the goal. When employees are
involved in goal setting, they have a much
better understanding of the goal, as well as
how to achieve it.
Module 7–6
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
4. Feedback
An individual must know when he or she has
achieved a set goal. It is important to have
progressive feedback on goal attainment.
B. Empowerment
Employee empowerment is a philosophy of
transferring power from management to
employees. By doing this, employees become
more involved in their work and accept
responsibility for their actions. Employees will be
more motivated to do quality work if they have
been involved in critical decisions and have a
sense of ownership in the job.
Even though empowerment is a strategy that
affects the entire organization, the basic
empowering relationship is between a supervisor
and subordinate. It is the immediate supervisor
who transfers power to an employee.
Section 5
The steps toward empowerment are listed below:
1. Develop an operational definition of
empowerment. The definition should be very
clear as to what empowerment means from
both the manager's perspective and the
employee's perspective. The goals and
objectives of empowerment should be stated
clearly and be behaviorally based in order to
evaluate the success of any intervention.
Module 7–7
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
2. Assess strategies used to empower
employees. Identify techniques that would be
appropriate for your group. This list will be
tentative and will be refined as more
information is gathered. Techniques include
participative decision making, job enrichment,
redesign of internal processes, etc.
3. Clarify and communicate organization/
division mission. An underlying assumption in
empowering employees is that their actions
will support the company's goals and
objectives. To ensure that this happens,
employees need to be very clear on the
company's goals and objectives. All
employees should know what their mission is
and how it fits into the overall mission of the
organization.
The goals and objectives of the division
should be concrete and expressed as specific
outcomes to be achieved. Employees will
need some guidelines for the decisions they
will be asked to make. The division goals and
objectives provide global guidance.
4. Determine the boundaries and limitations of
each strategy used. Decisions can be
classified into executive decisions and
operational decisions. Executive decisions
involve the overall mission of the organization,
the political climate, and the global strategy.
Operational decisions are day-to-day
decisions made in developing the "product." It
is important to know which decisions
employees will be able to make on their own.
Module 7–8
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
There are also organizational and regulatory
restrictions in decision making that must be
clarified. These decisions include fiscal
decisions, standard operating procedures
within the organization, restrictions imposed
by DOE, etc. Identifying decisions that are
not appropriate for participative decision
making will narrow down those decisions that
are appropriate.
5. Assuming participative decision making is to
be used, determine what decisions are
appropriate to delegate. Once boundaries
and limitations are defined, come up with a
tentative outline for the types of decisions that
are appropriate for sharing with employees
and those that are not appropriate. This
outline is tentative and requires input from
other managers, employees, and the
administration prior to being implemented.
6. Decide whether empowerment strategies will
be required or voluntary. Will a manager or
employee have a choice of whether he/she
will participate? What degree of
delegation/empowerment will be required?
7. Communicate the tentative plan to managers,
supervisors, and the administration. Prior to
getting input from employees, get initial input
from managers, supervisors, and the
administration. This information will help
determine the feasibility of employee
empowerment.
Module 7–9
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
Section 6
8. Get input from employees. Find out their
concept of empowerment. Determine to what
degree employees already feel empowered.
This can be done through a survey (preferably
anonymously). This step is risky because it
can raise expectations. This should only be
done if you have definite plans to proceed.
However, it should be done prior to
developing an elaborate strategy for
empowering employees.
If the goal of empowerment is motivational,
you have to find out what the employees
want. On the other hand, if the goal of
empowerment is to reduce the work load of
middle management, you have to get
employee buy-in; otherwise, it will flop.
9. Determine skills necessary for empowerment.
It cannot be assumed that managers and
employees have the skills necessary to
transfer power. The first step is to determine
what skills are necessary for shifting power.
Managers will need the skills necessary to
determine what decisions are appropriate for
staff to make.
Employees must know how to make
decisions, how to prioritize, when not to make
decisions, what the boundaries are, etc.
Once the skills have been identified, it is
important to know who has the requisite skills
and who doesn't. Some type of assessment
is necessary.
Module 7–10
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
10. Communicate plan to employees and provide
a mechanism for feedback. Introduction to
the plan should be low-key and not raise
expectations. Consider having each program,
or supervisor, communicate the plan as
opposed to an announcement from the
division office. This will help keep the focus
on the program.
11. Provide training if needed. Based on the
assessment of skills, training may be
necessary for those managers and employees
lacking requisite skills.
C. What other tools could be used to motivate
employees?
Module 7–11
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
This page intentionally left blank.
Module 7–12
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
I. Introduction
II. Leadership
A supervisor is more than just a person who sees
that a job is conducted and a task completed in
accord with directions; he/she is also a leader. The
more an organization rewards it’s effective leaders,
the fewer employee problems they will have.
A. Definition of leadership
Leadership is a process that includes influencing:
• The objectives and strategies of a group or
organization
• People in the organization to implement the
strategies and achieve the objectives
• Group maintenance and identification
• The culture of the organization.
B. Characteristics of good leadership
The characteristics of good leadership can be
placed in the following categories:
• Leadership traits
• Motives of leaders
• Leadership skills
Module 8–1
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
1. Leadership traits
• High energy level
• Stress tolerance
• Integrity
• Emotional maturity
• Self-confidence
2. Motives of leaders
• Need for power
• Need for achievement
• Need for affiliation
3. Effective leadership skills
• Planning and organizing
• Problem solving
• Clarifying and monitoring
• Informing
• Motivating and consulting
• Recognizing and supporting
• Team building, networking, and delegating
• Developing and mentoring
• Rewarding
Section 7
Module 8–2
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
C. Power/influence
1. Types of power
• Legitimate power - Supervisors have
legitimate power based on their position in
the organization.
• Coercive power - Supervisors have
coercive power based on their control (real
or perceived) over punishment.
• Reward power - Supervisors have reward
power based on their control (real or
perceived) over rewards.
• Expert power - Supervisors have expert
power based on their level of technical
expertise.
2. Influence tactics include the following:
• Rational persuasion
• Inspirational appeals
• Consultation
• Ingratiating
• Personal appeals
• Upward appeals
Module 8–3
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
III. Tools of leadership
A. Providing vision
A good leader provides vision for the work unit.
The vision is a clear, concise view of what the
work unit is striving to accomplish. The vision for
the work unit should be consistent with the vision
of the organization.
Ideally, the vision for the work unit will be
developed with input by the work unit.
If a vision is clearly stated and accepted by the
work unit, it becomes a goal of each member of
the unit.
B. Coaching/mentoring
One of the roles of a leader is to develop his or
her workers. Leaders are in the best position to
see individual efforts and how they help to
achieve or hinder goals. By coaching or
mentoring, a leader can guide a worker toward
goal attainment.
Coaching and mentoring include the following:
• Help each worker set goals and identify
barriers to overcome.
• Solicit ideas and assistance from workers in
solving problems that arise in the
organization.
• Know the deficiencies of employees and
develop a plan for them to acquire the
knowledge and skill needed. Feedback and
training will facilitate development of
employee knowledge and skills.
Module 8–4
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
• Reinforce positive behavior changes that
increase productivity.
C. Delegating
Part of a leader's role is to delegate tasks and
decisions to employees. The level of delegation
typically depends on one's style of leadership.
Some leaders feel comfortable in delegating
responsibility along with the delegated tasks,
while others feel more comfortable delegating
only the task.
Prior to delegating, a leader must consider the
following:
• Is the employee capable of completing the
assigned task?
• Does the employee have the necessary
resources to complete the task (human
resources, financial resources, training)?
• What are the consequences of failure? The
supervisor will have to assess the level of risk
in the task and determine whether the
organization can assume the risk of error.
• What type of supervision is necessary? The
supervisor should decide how closely he or
she should be involved. This will be
contingent on the competency of the
employee, the level of risk associated with the
task, and the leadership style of the
supervisor.
Module 8–5
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
D. Team building
An effective way of leading a group of individuals
is to allow them to lead themselves. The use of
self-managed work teams can be an effective
way to motivate employees to work more
efficiently and to work together.
Section 8
The concept of self-managed work teams
focuses on the team member as the expert. By
allowing the team to make and implement
decisions, decisions are being made by those
individuals with the most knowledge and
experience.
The following organizational context factors will
increase the likelihood of success for teams:
• Management support
• Mission clarity
• Autonomy
• Rewards for the team
• Team training
• Feedback on performance
• Organization culture conducive to teamwork
• Appropriate physical facility
Module 8–6
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
The following team development factors will
increase the likelihood of success:
• Communication
• Cohesion
• Developed norms
• Role clarity
• Cooperation
• Participation
• Conflict resolution
Module 8–7
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Student’s Guide
Notes
This page intentionally left blank.
Module 8–8
Part 5 of 5
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Handouts
Office of Environment, Safety & Health
U.S. Department of Energy
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Handouts
This page intentionally left blank.
ii
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Handouts
Table of Contents
Page
Choosing the Correct Workers.........................................................................................1
The Communication Process...........................................................................................2
Internal Exposure and Contamination During Pump Removal.........................................3
Fire in a Contaminated Cutting Facility ...........................................................................4
Supervisor’s Responsibilities ...........................................................................................6
Suggested Answer Key to Choosing the Correct Workers.............................................10
iii
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Handouts
This page intentionally left blank.
iv
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Handouts
Choosing the Correct Workers
Your site has an administrative control level (ACL) of 700 mrem. There are seven workers
in your group who are qualified to do a hot job requiring three individuals (one job leader
and two workers). You have the information below.
AGE Lifetime Dose- Current Annual
to-Date Rem Dose-to-Date mrem
Barbie 25 .7 150
Cleo 40 2.5 250
Egmont 50 55.0 100
Harpo 65 31.0 250
Julius 35 6.5 400
Tito 30 24.5 300
Selda 55 17.0 300
It’s Tuesday and the job is to be done Friday. The job leader will get 200 mrem and the
other two will get between 300 and 400 mrem. It's near the end of the year, so it looks as
though there will be no work involving any significant dose after this job until well into next
year.
Egmont, your most experienced worker, is restricted to 200 mrem per year because of an
incident several years ago which put his lifetime (committed) dose over his age in Rem.
Harpo is going in for an outpatient radioactive test Thursday. Julius is new, so you are
reluctant to choose him to be the leader, and Barbie and Selda don't have experiences to
be the leader. (All the others do)
Section 9
Cleo has just quietly told you she is pregnant. She will get the declaration form signed
Monday, when your group secretary gets back from vacation and can type up the form as
management requires. Barbie was saying only last month that she and her husband
Chancy are "trying" and she hopes she gets pregnant right away. You have no idea if she
has succeeded. Tito used to be a "jumper" in the nuclear power industry but has gotten
married and settled down. He says he and his wife want a family "real soon."
Which workers should you choose? Why?
Handouts 1
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Handouts
SENDER SENDER'S SENDER'S RECEIVER'S RECEIVER
FILTER MESSAGE FILTER
IDEA WORDS UNDERSTANDING
NON-VERBALS OF MESSAGE
FEEDBACK
CHECK BACK FOR
UNDERSTANDING
Handouts 2
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Handouts
Internal Exposure and Contamination During Pump Removal
A work crew was assigned to rebuild a small pump in a non-radioactive system located in
an uncontaminated radiation area. In accordance with good ALARA practices, the work
plan called for removal of the pump to a shop area for the repairs. The work supervisor
and the Radiological Control Technician (RCT) inspected and surveyed the pump area
together to discuss the radiological conditions and radiological controls necessary for the
job. The small pump was bolted to a metal mounting plate which was in turn bolted to
anchors on a concrete ledge. The plan was to remove the piping, unbolt the pump from the
mounting plate, have it surveyed for release, and carry it out to the shop. Since the system
was not radioactive, any contamination would be external. The RCT surveyed all
accessible areas of the pump and found no removable contamination. He also used cotton
swabs to check the area between the bottom of the pump and the base plate. Again no
removable contamination was found. He allowed the job to proceed with no protective
clothing on a routine radiation area maintenance Radiation Work Permit.
When the crew tried to unbolt the pump from the base plate they found that some of the
bolts were rusty and could not be removed. They contacted the supervisor and were given
the okay to try the anchor bolts holding the base plate to the concrete ledge. They
removed the pump and base plate and exited the area. Upon frisking out of the building,
two of the workers were contaminated at various locations on both skin and clothing. One
worker had positive nasal smears and the pump was contaminated. The highest levels of
contamination were on the underside of the base plate.
The room where the pump was located had been flooded with highly contaminated water in
an incident several years ago. All accessible areas of the room were subsequently
decontaminated to undetectable levels and routine access without protective equipment
had been restored.
Handouts 3
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Handouts
Fire in a Contaminated Cutting Facility
Section 10
An area was set aside in a decontamination facility to be used to reduce the size of metal
contaminated waste by cutting large pieces into smaller pieces for easier handling and
disposal. Since some of the cutting operations employed oxygen-acetylene cutting torches,
the area had to be approved in accordance with the plant fire protection program.
The plant fire protection engineer inspected the facility and developed a procedure to
control the use of cutting torches in the facility. The procedure required:
1. A metal enclosure that would prevent the passing of slag and sparks to
surrounding areas had to be constructed and equipped with a portable
ventilation unit.
2. Two fully charged fire extinguishers and a fire watch must be present in the
area at all times while torch cutting is in progress.
3. Removal of all loose combustible materials from the facility before torch cutting
operations begin.
4. Protection of any fixed combustible materials with fire retardant materials.
5. No storage of combustible materials within forty feet of the cutting enclosure.
A welder and a fire watch were assigned to cut up several large pieces of steel in the
facility. When operation had been underway for several minutes, the fire watch noticed
flames in the corner of the facility. He notified the welder to stop cutting operations and
picked up one of the two fire extinguishers only to find it empty. He then took the second
fire extinguisher and put the fire out.
The investigation determined that the fire had started in a pile of paper towels in the corner
and would soon have spread to the unprotected combustible ventilation trunk which had
been moved from its original protected location several weeks earlier for better smoke
control.
Interviews with the workers involved and other workers who were periodically assigned to
work in the facility revealed that they were not satisfied with the safety conditions in the
facility in general and one had mentioned it to the supervisor. Since work force cut-backs
and lay-offs were expected, no one wanted to "make waves."
Handouts 4
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Handouts
Fire in a Contaminated Cutting Facility (continued)
The supervisor of the area was tasked by management to "...bring the facility into full
compliance with the fire protection program and procedures before resuming torch cutting
operations."
All loose combustible materials in the facility were removed and all fixed combustible
materials were protected.
Two days after resumption of torch cutting operations, a passing technician noticed a fire in
some bags of trash stored outside the facility metal wall. He found the nearest fire
extinguisher and put out the fire.
Follow-up investigation found that the seam where the metal wall met the floor had been
separated by visible damage allowing the passage of sparks outside the wall. Further
inspection of the area found numerous instances of combustible materials stored within the
forty foot limit.
None of the workers in the facility during the two occurrences were aware of the procedural
requirements specific to that facility.
Handouts 5
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Handouts
Supervisor’s Responsibilities
I. Radiological Control Documents
A. 10 CFR 835
• Codified DOE radiation protection requirements
• Applies to all persons (§835.3)
• Forms basis for potential civil and criminal penalties under the Price-Anderson
Section 11
Amendments Act
• Requires a DOE-approved Radiation Protection Program for all DOE radiological
activities
B. Radiological Control Standard
• Establishes DOE's views on the proper course of action in radiological control
• Includes best-practices guidance
• Includes use of Site-Specific Radiological Control Manual
II. Supervisor Involvement and Accountability
A. Review work in advance
• Participate in review of nonroutine or complex work activities exceeding site
trigger levels requiring reviews. These trigger levels are in the site-specific
Radiological Control Manual.
• Approve the Radiological Work Permit (RWP) with the Radiological Control
Supervisor.
• Conduct pre-job briefing prior to work exceeding the trigger levels.
B. Walk your space
• As part of their normal work review, supervisors should periodically review
ongoing jobs to ensure prescribed radiological controls are being implemented,
and good work practices followed.
Handouts 6
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Handouts
Supervisor’s Responsibilities (continued)
• Periodically monitor the work areas.
• Conditions that could lead to or promote spread of contamination, or unsafe
work, should be corrected on a priority basis.
III. Conduct a safe operation
A. Abnormal conditions
• Although the organization is established and operates to assure worker
protection, it is not infallible.
• The line supervisor is the last line of defense for the worker should the system
fail or should a deficiency occur in the workplace, such as with ventilation
controls, air monitors, instrumentation, fire control systems, etc.
• Act upon abnormal situations or signals immediately, whether from your own
observation or brought to you by workers.
• Assure that your workers know the alarms for abnormal conditions, and know
their appropriate response.
B. Assure adequate training
• Although training in most cases is provided by the training organization, the
responsibility for quality and effectiveness rests with line management.
• Assure workers have the training required for entry. If the training requirement is
not in the posting or in the RWP.
IV. Control the spread of contamination
• Assure that material is not removed to uncontrolled areas without survey.
• Assure cleanliness and good housekeeping in the work area.
• Reduce materials entering radiological areas to minimize waste generation and
potential for fire.
Handouts 7
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Handouts
Supervisor’s Responsibilities (continued)
V. Reduce worker exposure
A. Administrative dose limits
• Your workers should not be allowed to go above the facility Administrative
Control Level for dose without the prior approval of the contractor senior site
executive.
• Approval by the appropriate Secretarial Officer or designee should be obtained
prior to allowing a person to exceed 2,000 mrem.
B. Use the RWP
• Verify that entry points to radiological work areas and radiation areas are posted
to state basic entry requirements, such as dosimetry, Radiological Work Permits
(RWP) and respiratory equipment required. The dose rate and contamination
level or range of each should be included in the posting.
• Ensure that your workers have read, understood and will comply with the RWP.
• Assure that workers use the dosimetry, personal protective equipment and
clothing prescribed in the RWP.
C. Assure good work practices
Section 12
• Assure that your workers follow good radiological control practices, such as when
frisking and removing protective clothing.
• Stop work and obtain guidance if during the use of procedures, a written
requirement cannot be responsibly followed.
• Recognize that any worker through their supervisor has the authority and
responsibility to stop radiological work activities for any of the following reasons:
– Inadequate radiological control
– Radiological controls not being implemented
– Radiological Control Hold Point not satisfied
Handouts 8
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Handouts
Supervisor’s Responsibilities (continued)
VI. Supervisory Training Requirements
Supervisory skills training include the following (or equivalent):
• Leadership
• Interpersonal communication
• Responsibilities and authority
• Motivation of personnel
• Problem analysis and decision making
• Fitness for duty procedures
• Administrative policies and procedures (These will generally be site-specific.)
Handouts 9
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Handouts
Choosing the Correct Workers
Suggested Answer Key
Whom to Choose?
Answer: One reasonable choice would be Barbie (400 mrem), Tito (200 mrem), and Selda
(300 mrem), with Tito as the leader. At the end of the year the final doses would look like
this:
Age Lifetime Dose- Current Annual
to-Date Rem Dose-to-Date mrem
Barbie 25 1.1 550
Cleo 40 2.5 250
Egmont 50 55.0 100
Harpo 65 31.0 250
Julius 35 6.5 400
Tito 30 24.7 500
Selda 55 17.3 600
Handouts 10
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Handouts
Workers Explanation
Egmont
He is restricted to 200 mrem/yr and he already has 100 mrem.
Harpo
He is scheduled to have a medical procedure involving a radioactive isotope.
The RadCon Standard recommends special consideration be given to
keeping down the occupational doses of those receiving additional doses for
medical purposes. If he ingested a radioactive isotope during the medical
procedure on Thursday, during monitoring for contamination on Friday the
frisker may not be able to identify whether the dose was from an internal or
external source.
Julius
He can't be the leader. He also can't receive the 300 to 400 mrem dose
unless you get special permission to exceed the ACL of 700 mrem per year.
NOTE: If he does not participate, he will still end up the year as the median
person of the group in terms of dose, so by not choosing him you are not
favoring him.
Barbie
The genetic risk effects due to irradiation of sperm and unfertilized eggs at
these dose levels are considered to be extremely low. The important risk is
to a developing embryo-fetus.
Cleo
Technically she has not declared her pregnancy in written form, however,
management should not put unreasonable obstacles in the way of a woman
being able to declare her pregnancy. The best route to take is to get her to
write in the information on the form until the secretary returns.
Handouts 11
Radiological Control Training for Supervisors
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
Handouts
This page intentionally left blank.
Handouts 12
DOE-HDBK-1143-2001
CONCLUDING MATERIAL
Review Activity: Preparing Activity:
DOE Field Offices DOE-EH-52
DP RF Peter V. O’Connell, CHP, 301 903 5641
EH ID Project Number:
EM SR TRNG-0017
NE OH
SC RL
GC
IA
RW
NN
National Laboratories Operations Offices
BNL AL
LLNL NV
LANL OAK
PNL OR
Sandia CH
ANL
New Brunswick
ORNL
Area Offices
Amarillo Area Office
Kirtland Area Office
Princeton Area Office
Fernald Area Office
Kansas City Area Office
Miamisburg Area Office